---
title: "Critical materials ETFs fell as much as 40% in three months while Shanghai copper and heavy rare earths stay scarce"
url: "https://etf.net/news/critical-materials-etfs-tumble-2026-11-18"
published_at: "2026-11-18T15:34:24.547Z"
updated_at: "2026-11-18T16:55:36.823Z"
byline: "ETF.net Research"
---

# Critical materials ETFs fell as much as 40% in three months while Shanghai copper and heavy rare earths stay scarce

Rare-earth, lithium and copper miner funds have been sold alongside AI stocks, even as copper in China and heavy rare earths outside the country remain in short supply.

By ETF.net Research. Published Nov 18, 2026.

Copper futures fell 5.8% by 10:19 a.m. ET on Wednesday, to about $5.64 a pound, and the Global X Copper Miners ETF, COPX, the biggest fund in this corner of the market, dropped 6.8%. On Tuesday, billionaire investor Stan Druckenmiller [told the TomorrowX conference](https://www.coindesk.com/business/2026/11/17/druckenmiller-says-he-is-short-copper-warns-of-economic-weakness-in-2027) in Austin, Texas, that he was betting against copper. "I'm really alert to the fact that the second half of '27 could be economically disappointing," he said.

The selloff is broader than one day and one metal. In the three months through Tuesday's close, the VanEck Rare Earth and Strategic Metals ETF, REMX, lost 39.5% of its price. The Sprott Critical Materials ETF, SETM, lost 33.9%. As of Wednesday morning, REMX traded 59% below its 52-week high.

Yet some of these metals are genuinely scarce, at least in particular places. Copper stocks in Shanghai Futures Exchange warehouses fell 18% last week to an almost three-year low, Shanghai Metals Market reported. In Europe, the price of dysprosium oxide, a heavy rare earth, stood at about 16.3 times the Chinese price by the end of the third quarter, according to price assessor [Benchmark Mineral Intelligence](https://source.benchmarkminerals.com/article/ex-china-heavy-rare-earths-continue-to-surge-q3-2026-rare-earths-price-review).

Elsewhere, the picture is looser. Copper in London Metal Exchange (LME) warehouses rose to 329,100 metric tons in the week to Nov. 13, from about 205,000 in mid-August. Benchmark describes the light rare earths that Western miners mostly sell as oversupplied, and lithium is forecast to tip into surplus next year.

However, investors in REMX, SETM and many other similar funds typically own shares in mining companies, not the metals, and those shares have been moving on forces that have little to do with what sits in warehouses.

## Copper is trading like an AI stock

Goldman Sachs analysts wrote last week that copper's price has tracked a basket of AI data-center stocks since late 2025, and that its recent decline was "largely driven by the volatility in AI-related equities." Those stocks sold off after the Democratic sweep in the midterm elections, Goldman said, and investors grew more cautious still after Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia's chief executive on Nov. 12, [Reuters reported](https://www.brecorder.com/news/40448766/copper-falls-heads-for-fifth-straight-weekly-drop-on-ai-rout).

Bets on more Federal Reserve rate increases also lifted the dollar to a 19-month high on Tuesday, which makes dollar-priced metals more expensive for buyers using other currencies, Reuters noted.

"The sell-off in AI-related shares has raised concerns around the demand outlook for copper, given the metal's growing exposure to investment in power grids and data centers," ING commodities strategist Ewa Manthey [told Reuters](https://www.brecorder.com/news/40449359).

Goldman put the correction down to investor positioning rather than loosening fundamentals. Bloomberg pointed to a second force on Wednesday: growing doubt that the Trump administration will put tariffs on refined copper, a prospect that had pulled large shipments into the U.S. and tightened supply in other markets.

Not everyone thinks demand is intact. Nicholas Snowdon, head of metals and mining research at Mercuria Energy Group, told a conference in Shanghai on Wednesday that, despite strong global growth, copper demand looks closer to a recession than an expansion, Bloomberg reported.

## In rare earths, the scarce metals are not the ones Western miners sell

The rare-earth story makes sense once you separate heavy elements from light ones, and the Chinese rule in force from the one on hold. In force: China's April 2025 export licensing of seven medium and heavy rare earths, dysprosium and terbium among them, which was never suspended. On hold: a broader package of curbs announced in October 2025, now paused until Jan. 10, 2027. With licensing still biting, Bloomberg reported this month that some rare earths trade abroad at "enormous multiples" of their price inside China.

Western producers mainly sell a light rare earth, NdPr oxide, and its price has gone the other way. Benchmark's assessments show NdPr delivered to North America and Europe [slipped below](https://source.benchmarkminerals.com/article/ex-china-ndpr-prices-slip-below-110-kg-price-floor-as-oversupply-builds) the $110-a-kilogram floor in MP Materials' and Lynas' agreements with the U.S. Defense Department in August. MP shares were about 51% below their 52-week high on Wednesday morning, even after rising 8% that day, while REMX slipped about 1% and COPX fell nearly 7%.

The most direct play on the theme is the Sprott Rare Earths Ex-China ETF, REXC, launched in April at a 0.65% fee. In Sprott's description, its index tracks companies that mine, separate, refine and produce rare earths, "while excluding companies domiciled in or primarily operating in China." It lost 38.4% in the three months through Tuesday, nearly as much as REMX.

## A rare-earth fund led by lithium, a lithium fund led by Rio Tinto

On Nov. 16, REMX's two largest holdings were lithium producers, Albemarle at 8.88% and SQM at 8.59%, according to VanEck's holdings page. With Australian lithium miner PLS Group, its three lithium names made up 23.4% of the fund, against 22.1% for its three largest rare-earth holdings, China Northern Rare Earth, Lynas and MP.

Chart: Lithium producers are the **largest** names in REMX

The full name allows for that, since index provider MarketVector [counts lithium](https://www.vaneck.com/us/en/blogs/natural-resources/remx-question-and-answer/) as a strategic metal, but a buyer drawn in by rare earths gets about as much lithium.

That matters because the lithium outlook has turned. Chile's copper commission, Cochilco, on Nov. 12 forecast a lithium surplus of 42,000 tons, measured as lithium carbonate, in 2027, after a 79,000-ton deficit in 2026. It expects demand growth to slow from 25% to 8%.

The Global X Lithium & Battery Tech ETF, LIT, is less of a lithium fund than its name suggests. On Nov. 16 its largest holding was Rio Tinto, a diversified global miner, at 19.91% of the fund. The rest runs from lithium producers to battery makers and Tesla.

Chart: Rio Tinto is the **largest** holding in the lithium ETF

SETM is the broadest of the group, with 157 holdings. Its Sept. 30 allocations, per Sprott, were 27% copper, 23.5% uranium, 17.6% silver, 17.3% lithium and 10.8% rare earths. Almost a quarter of a fund called "critical materials" is in uranium, so its holders are partly betting on nuclear power. Each issuer posts full holdings on the fund's web page, where these weights can be checked as they change.

Table: Fund, Fee, 3 months, 1 year, 3 years, etf.net grade

*Price returns through the Nov. 17 close. COPX is graded among copper-miner funds; the others among critical-materials funds.*

Falls this steep are not new for these funds. Measured from September 2021 through Tuesday, REMX at its worst stood 74% below an earlier peak and LIT 67%, and over five years their prices are down 62% and 41%.

REMX nonetheless ranks first of 12 funds in etf.net's Critical Materials category. The grade compares a fund only with its category peers, on cost, risk, tradability, holdings, durability and, where it can be tested, whether the fund did what it promised; it does not forecast returns. Its risk measure covers behavior in falling markets over one- and three-year windows, against peers that fell too, not the latest quarter. On inputs a holder can check, REMX charges a fee only the iShares Lithium Miners and Producers ETF undercuts, at 0.47%; held $1.45 billion at the end of October, according to VanEck; averaged about 920,000 shares a day over the past month; and has run since 2010.

## Thursday's Trump-Xi meeting is the next test for rare-earth holders

President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping meet Thursday in Shenzhen, where Washington wants "concrete actions" on rare earths. Bank of America economist Anna Zhou wrote that she expects the meeting "to focus on managing downside risks rather than delivering a major agreement." The Council on Foreign Relations' Joshua Kurlantzick wrote that even if the export truce is extended, "China is still stalling on allowing rare earths out of the country."

U.S. chip policy adds a further risk. After Huang's exit, Kenton Thibaut of the Atlantic Council [warned](https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/content-series/fastthinking/what-jensen-huangs-nvidia-exit-means-for-washington-wall-street-and-beijing) that tougher U.S. controls could invite retaliation: "Beijing could answer new restrictions with curbs on critical minerals or probes of other American firms." After Thursday come the Fed's Dec. 9 meeting, where CME FedWatch data show a rate increase fully priced, and Jan. 10, when China's pause runs out.

For someone holding or weighing these funds, the useful question is which risk each one carries: copper's link to AI spending in COPX and in more than a quarter of SETM; lithium's slide toward surplus in LIT and in nearly a quarter of REMX; the rare-earth policy calendar in REXC and REMX; and, in SETM, uranium and silver as well.

Source: etf.net, https://etf.net/news/critical-materials-etfs-tumble-2026-11-18. Please cite the page URL.
