---
title: "VYM vs. VIG: Vanguard's high-yield ETF is the better pick, unless VIG is your only stock fund"
url: "https://etf.net/news/vym-vs-vig-dividend-etf-comparison-2026-11-18"
published_at: "2026-11-18T16:22:31.019Z"
updated_at: "2026-11-18T16:22:31.019Z"
byline: "ETF.net Research"
---

# VYM vs. VIG: Vanguard's high-yield ETF is the better pick, unless VIG is your only stock fund

Both charge 0.04% and share about 61% of their portfolios, but VYM pays more and fell less, while VIG raises its payout faster.

By ETF.net Research. Published Nov 18, 2026.

For most investors choosing between these two, Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF VYM is the better buy. Since Vanguard's [Feb. 1 fee cuts](https://corporate.vanguard.com/content/dam/corp/articles/pdf/expense_ratio_reduction_jan2026.pdf), it costs the same 0.04% a year as Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF VIG. It pays about 2.3% in trailing dividends against VIG's 1.5%. It beat VIG over one, three and five years to Sept. 30, and its worst price drop over the past five years was shallower. VIG wins on one use: as your only stock fund, with every dividend reinvested, its faster-growing payout, 10-year record and big growth companies make it the stronger choice.

The decision also matters less than owners fear. Line the two portfolios up stock by stock, keep only the amount both funds hold, and **60.6%** of each fund is left.

## Two indexes with opposite ideas about yield

VIG tracks the [S&P U.S. Dividend Growers Index](https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/documents/methodologies/methodology-sp-dividend-growers-index-series.pdf), which requires 10 straight years of dividend increases, then drops the highest-yielding 25% of the companies that qualify. VYM tracks the [FTSE High Dividend Yield Index](https://www.lseg.com/content/dam/ftse-russell/en_us/documents/ground-rules/ftse-high-dividend-yield-index-ground-rules-redacted.pdf), which excludes real estate investment trusts (REITs) and non-payers and aims for "relatively high forecast dividend yields." Both weight stocks by market value.

So VIG sheds the kind of stock VYM is built to find, while the two agree across the broad middle of steady payers. Each fund trailed its index by 0.07 percentage point or less over every period on Vanguard's Sept. 30 fact sheets, so return gaps belong to the indexes, not to how Vanguard runs either fund.

## VIG's own stocks are a few megacaps; VYM's are spread over 381

The funds weight the 208 companies they share almost identically; JPMorgan Chase is 3.7% of VIG and 3.6% of VYM. Broadcom is the exception, at 6.1% of VYM and 3.8% of VIG.

The stocks only one fund owns are about 36.6% of each, but they look nothing alike. In VIG, seven companies VYM doesn't own make up about **23%** of the fund: Apple, Eli Lilly, Microsoft, Visa, Walmart, Mastercard and Costco. In VYM, that share is spread over 381 companies, and the nine largest, from Chevron and Philip Morris to Verizon and Pfizer, add up to about 9%.

Chart: Seven stocks VYM doesn't own are **23%** of VIG

Vanguard's Sept. 30 sector figures show the result: technology is 26.7% of VIG but 14.3% of VYM, and energy 3.6% against 10.1%. VIG holds 333 stocks, with 34.5% in its top 10; VYM holds 593, with 26.2%.

## Returns: VYM has led lately, VIG over 10 years

Table: , VIG, VYM

*Total returns at net asset value (NAV) to Sept. 30, from Vanguard's fact sheets for [VIG](https://fund-docs.vanguard.com/F0920.pdf) and [VYM](https://fund-docs.vanguard.com/F0923.pdf). **Price only, Sept. 20, 2021, to Nov. 17, 2026.

VYM led by 0.91 percentage point a year over five years. VIG led by 1.58 percentage points a year over 10, enough to turn $10,000 into about $33,500 against $29,100 in VYM. The longer record favors VIG too: Bryan Armour of Morningstar found in a 2025 comparison that it returned 9.52% a year from January 2007 to May 2025, 1.15 percentage points a year more than VYM.

VIG also fell harder, with a deepest price drop over the past five years about 4 percentage points worse than VYM's. Size doesn't separate them: both are large, and Vanguard reports a median bid-ask spread of 0.01% for each.

## VYM pays more now; VIG raises its payout faster

On $100,000, VYM's trailing yield works out to about **$800** a year more cash than VIG's. VIG's answer is faster growth in that payout. Comparing the four payments to September 2026 with the four to September 2021, VIG's dividend per share grew about 7.4% a year and VYM's 4.4%; over 10 years, 7.8% and 5.6%. The latest 12 months broke the pattern: VYM's payout rose 4.5% and VIG's 2.7%.

The extra income costs more in a taxable account, where, [Vanguard notes](https://investor.vanguard.com/investor-resources-education/article/top-tax-questions-answered), dividends are taxed in the year you receive them. In a traditional IRA or 401(k), earnings are taxed only on withdrawal, so that concern largely falls away. VYM's index already leaves out REITs, which Vanguard's fact sheet says generally miss the lower tax rates on qualified dividends. Armour picked no outright winner: "Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF for those seeking current income, and Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF for those prioritizing long-term growth."

Beside an S&P 500 fund, the gap is modest. About 95% of VIG's weight is in companies Vanguard S&P 500 ETF VOO also owns, against 93% of VYM's, and VOO holds all seven of VIG's big unshared names. On the stock-by-stock measure, VIG repeats 42% of VOO and VYM 35%.

If you already own one in a taxable account, selling it is a taxable event, Vanguard's prospectus notes, and the switch would buy a portfolio about 61% the same.

## The call: VYM beside an index fund, VIG on its own

To sit beside a broad index fund, or to live on its payouts, choose VYM: it pays more, its price fell less over the past five years and it repeats a little less of an S&P 500 fund. As your whole stock portfolio, with dividends left alone for decades, VIG's faster dividend growth, growth companies and 10-year lead make it the better single holding.

Source: etf.net, https://etf.net/news/vym-vs-vig-dividend-etf-comparison-2026-11-18. Please cite the page URL.
