---
title: "XLE gained 44.5% this year on the Iran war's oil shock, while pipeline ETFs made about half as much"
url: "https://etf.net/news/xle-soars-on-iran-oil-shock-2026-11-18"
published_at: "2026-11-18T15:37:42.818Z"
updated_at: "2026-11-18T15:37:42.818Z"
byline: "ETF.net Research"
---

# XLE gained 44.5% this year on the Iran war's oil shock, while pipeline ETFs made about half as much

The largest energy ETF beat the S&P 500 by 36 percentage points through Nov. 17, a refiner fund did better still, and rules-based stock pickers lagged.

By ETF.net Research. Published Nov 18, 2026.

The State Street Energy Select Sector SPDR ETF XLE, the category's largest fund with $41 billion in assets, returned **44.5%** this year through Nov. 17, including dividends. The State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF SPY returned 8.2%, a gap of 36 percentage points. The cause was an oil shock from the war with Iran and the shutdown of the Strait of Hormuz, but the category's 24 funds met it very differently: the median fund returned 33.8%.

Chart: **XLE** returned 44.5% this year through Nov. 17

## Energy stocks rose with oil, but a futures fund rose more than twice as far

In September the International Energy Agency [forecast](https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/global-2026-oil-supply-gap-deepen-delayed-return-normal-gulf-flows-iea-says-2026-09-11) that global oil supply would fall about 6% this year. Brent futures closed Nov. 17 at $93.14, up 53% since Dec. 31.

These funds own oil companies, not barrels, and the year shows the difference. USCF's United States Brent Oil Fund BNO, which holds Brent futures, doubled in price this year, up 108%. XLE rose 42% in price, about two-fifths as much. The gap runs both ways: over the past month BNO fell 12.2% and XLE 6.5%.

## The third quarter rewarded refiners and punished pipelines

After the war resumed on July 8, U.S. crude futures went from $67 to $107 by mid-September, [Reuters reported](https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/us-oil-gas-production-rises-q3-2026-price-uncertainty-plagues-producers-dallas-2026-09-30). XLE returned 16.5% in the quarter, SPY 2.4%.

Refiners did best. The VanEck Oil Refiners ETF CRAK rose 37.5% in price over the quarter. Fund manager Cohen & Steers [pointed to](https://resources.cohenandsteers.com/Reports/Commentary_P-REPMEMLP.pdf) "record-high crack spreads", the margin between crude and the fuels made from it, as damaged refineries and fewer Chinese fuel exports shrank global refining capacity.

The refining boom reached XLE through the oil majors. Exxon Mobil and Chevron make up 42.5% of the fund. In the third quarter Exxon's refining business [earned](https://investor.exxonmobil.com/sec-filings/all-sec-filings/content/0002115436-26-000020/0002115436-26-000020.pdf) $7.2 billion, up from $1.8 billion a year earlier, and Chevron's [earned](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/93410/000009341026000196/a09302026ex9918-k.htm) $4.9 billion, up from $1.1 billion: about four times as much in all.

Pipeline funds lost money in the same quarter. The Alerian Energy Infrastructure ETF ENFR returned −2.9%, and two other pipeline funds fell slightly more.

Chart: **CRAK** gained 37.5%; three pipeline funds lost money

Their managers disagree on why. ALPS, which sponsors ENFR, [blamed](https://www.alpsfunds.com/hubfs/alps-docs/lit/insight/alerian-energy-infrastructure-etf-enfr-insights-20260930.pdf) rising long-term interest rates: in September the 10-year Treasury yield reached 5.28%, its highest since 2007, and the fund fell 8.66%. It also notes that about 70% of the fund is natural gas infrastructure.

Westwood, which runs energy-income funds, [said](https://westwoodgroup.com/assets/mlp-sma-newsletter/) pipeline stocks fell in September "as flows through the Strait of Hormuz increased, causing declines in oil prices," and gas-oriented names suffered from "growing data center opposition."

## Plain U.S. energy index funds landed near the top; rules-based stock pickers lagged

Funds that simply own the big U.S. energy companies finished within 5 percentage points of one another, whatever they charged. The Strive U.S. Energy ETF DRLL, at 0.41%, led; the iShares U.S. Energy ETF IYE, at 0.37%, beat the Fidelity MSCI Energy Index ETF FENY and the Vanguard Energy ETF VDE, which charge less than a quarter as much. XLE, FENY and VDE hold the category's only A grades from etf.net, which weigh cost, risk and trading, not returns alone.

Two funds that choose stocks by other rules trailed: the First Trust Energy AlphaDEX Fund FXN, which uses a quantitative selection method, and the Invesco Dorsey Wright Energy Momentum ETF PXI, which favors stocks with strong recent price trends; PXI finished 15 percentage points behind XLE.

Table: Fund, Fee, Return this year, Third quarter

*Total returns through Nov. 17; \*price returns, excluding dividends. Category median this year: 33.8%.*

## Since September, oil traders have started talking about a surplus

On Nov. 4, after Republicans lost control of Congress in the midterm elections, Brent fell 8.7% as investors bet the shift could hasten the end of the war, [Reuters reported](https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-edges-down-investors-await-us-midterm-election-results-2026-11-04); XLE fell 4.7%. On the morning of Nov. 18 Brent traded at $92.20, 23% below its 52-week high.

"For the first time since the US-Iran conflict began, traders are actively contemplating the possibility of excess supply rather than persistent tightness," Tim Waterer, chief analyst at the broker KCM Trade, told [CNBC](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/16/oil-prices-fall-on-expectations-of-coming-supply-surplus.html).

The largest fund has held up better than oil. From Sept. 30 to Nov. 17, Brent futures fell 5% and BNO 1.9%, while XLE rose 3% in price.

## Record money came in this year; the 10-year record is weaker

U.S.-listed energy sector ETFs took in $12.2 billion this year through October, already more than in any full year, State Street [reported](https://www.ssga.com/library-content/pdfs/etf/us/monthly-flash-flows.pdf). In the week of the midterms, holders pulled $382 million from the iShares Global Energy ETF IXC, its largest weekly outflow in a year, [ETFIQ](https://etfiq.com/flows/weekly/2026-11-06/) data show.

Over five years XLE rose 115% in price, double the 57% of SPY. Over 10 years it rose 79%, against 234%, and in 2020 alone it lost 37%.

## The government forecast assumes Gulf output recovers by mid-2027

The U.S. Energy Information Administration's [November outlook](https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/archives/Nov26.pdf) assumes most Middle East output outside Iran returns to pre-conflict levels by mid-2027. On that basis it forecasts Brent averaging $97 this year and $86 next year, falling to $77 by late 2027. The agency also warned that flows through Hormuz "will remain susceptible to disruption."

What the year established is that the slice of energy a fund owns mattered far more than its fee. A refiner fund, a pipeline fund and a broad fund are all labeled energy, but in the third quarter they moved in opposite directions.

Source: etf.net, https://etf.net/news/xle-soars-on-iran-oil-shock-2026-11-18. Please cite the page URL.
