AGG vs BNDX: AGG is the better core bond fund, and BNDX belongs beside it, not in its place
AGG costs less than half as much and pays more each month. Its yield edge over BNDX is smaller than it looks, and since BNDX owns none of AGG's bonds, it belongs beside AGG rather than in its place.

Key takeaways
For a U.S.-based investor who wants one bond fund, the iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF AGG is the better choice over the Vanguard Total International Bond ETF BNDX. It charges 0.03% a year against 0.07% and pays larger, steadier monthly income. BNDX's headline yield is lower but leaves out what its currency hedge earns. It has the slightly better record over most windows and has been calmer to hold. Since it owns no bonds that AGG owns, the real choice is whether to add it, not which fund to keep.
Two funds with no bonds in common
AGG tracks the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index of investment-grade dollar bonds: Treasuries (about 47% of the fund), government-backed mortgage pools and corporate bonds. It had $138 billion in net assets on Nov. 11, according to iShares.
BNDX tracks the hedged Bloomberg Global Aggregate ex-USD index of investment-grade bonds issued in other currencies. Its ETF shares had $84.9 billion in net assets on Oct. 31, out of $124.2 billion across all share classes, per Vanguard.
Because one index is dollar-only and the other excludes the dollar, the portfolios share no securities. BNDX hedges its currencies with forward contracts, so its returns depend mainly on interest rates in Europe, Japan and Britain, not on the euro or the yen.
Returns and duration as of Sept. 30, 2026, from each issuer's fact sheet; yields on the dates shown.
Duration measures rate sensitivity: 6.4 years means a price drop of roughly 6.4% if yields rise one percentage point. BNDX is the more rate-sensitive fund, just to different rates.
BNDX's record is a little better, and its index explains why
BNDX leads over one, five and 10 years; AGG leads over three. The decade's gap of about 0.2 percentage points a year belongs to the markets, not the managers: BNDX's index returned 1.42% a year against 1.13% for AGG's. BNDX actually trailed its index by more, 0.12 percentage points a year against 0.02.
This year shows why owning both helps. The 10-year Treasury yield has risen 94 basis points, nearly a full percentage point, to 5.12% on Nov. 16.
Treasury yields are higher than at year-end
With payouts added back, AGG has lost about 1.4% this year while BNDX is up about 0.1%. Since September 2021, on daily prices, BNDX's annualized volatility was 5.4% against 6.1% for AGG, and its worst peak-to-trough fall 18.6% against 21.1%.
That cushion has limits. Bonds abroad fell with U.S. bonds in 2022, and over the five years to Nov. 16 the two funds' price declines were nearly identical, about 17% each. Hedging removes currency swings. It does not remove interest-rate risk. And diversification cuts both ways: if U.S. rates fall on their own, AGG's bonds rally while BNDX's need not, and a narrower gap in short-term rates would shrink BNDX's hedge return.
BNDX's lower yield leaves out its hedge, and its payouts are lumpy
The Securities and Exchange Commission's standard 30-day SEC yield puts AGG 1.19 percentage points ahead. But it counts only what the bonds yield to maturity, not BNDX's hedge. A currency forward's price reflects the gap between two countries' short-term interest rates, so a dollar investor hedging out of lower-rate currencies collects that gap. Vanguard says headline yields on hedged foreign bonds "may not fully capture their total return potential."
Those differentials are wide. The Federal Reserve's target range is 3.75% to 4%, against 2.5% at the European Central Bank and 1.25% at the Bank of Japan: 1.25 to 1.5 percentage points a year to collect on euro bonds, 2.5 to 2.75 on yen bonds. The Bank of England's 4% rate leaves nothing on British bonds. France, Germany, Italy and Japan alone are 40% of BNDX. So the gap in what the two funds earn is well under 1.2 percentage points, as long as those rate gaps last.
The cash arrives unevenly. BNDX's last 12 payouts come to 4.67% of its current price, above AGG's 4.18% on the same basis, but 44% of BNDX's total came in one payment of $0.97 a share last December. Its regular monthly checks run nearer the 2.95% distribution yield Vanguard listed on Oct. 1. AGG is cheaper to hold, too: on $10,000, the fee is $3 a year against $7.
BNDX's credit mix cuts both ways, and taxes barely differ
BNDX has 25.7% of its bonds rated AAA against 2.2% at AGG, where about 74% is AA, mostly Treasuries and agency mortgages (iShares' credit table is undated). But BNDX also holds more BBB, the lowest investment-grade tier: 18.5% against 11.5%.
BNDX's prospectus warns that foreign taxes may be withheld from its income, claimable by shareholders only if the fund chooses to make a special election. For 2025 it did, but the foreign tax came to just 0.17% of its dividends, Vanguard reported, so holding BNDX in an IRA rather than a taxable account costs little on that score.
Buy AGG as your one bond fund, and add BNDX beside it to diversify
If you want a single bond fund to hold for years, buy AGG: it is cheaper, pays more each month and is the plainest way to own the U.S. bond market. BNDX's case is diversification against U.S. rates moving on their own, which paid off this year. If you want that, add it alongside AGG.
As a guide to how much, Vanguard's own target-date funds, from young savers' to retirees', keep about 30% of their conventional bonds in hedged international bonds. A split near 70/30 between AGG and BNDX keeps AGG's low cost and steady monthly income at the core while giving foreign rate markets a real say in your returns.
Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google


