Skip to content

Fund RadarNew ETFs

Brandywine Large Cap ETF buys puts on 45% and does not sell calls

Unlike the cheaper hedged funds, which sell calls to pay for protection, Brandywine seeks to cover the cost of its puts with a futures portfolio, at a total annual fee of 0.70%.

An orange lifebuoy is secured to a boat's railing above dark blue water.

Key takeaways

  • Brandywine Large Cap ETF buys puts on about 45% and keeps upside others give up.
  • Brandywine Large Cap ETF's 0.70% fee exceeds the cheaper funds that sell calls.
  • The filing gives no assurance futures will cover put costs, and they can lose money.
  • The puts are not a floor, and the fund can still take significant losses.
  • The adviser has no experience managing an ETF, which may limit its effectiveness.

Brandywine Asset Management's Brandywine Large Cap ETF BWLB started trading on NYSE Arca on Friday, Nov. 13. Under its Oct. 30 prospectus, the fund is set up to buy put options with a face value of about 45% of the portfolio, without selling calls to pay for them.

Three hedged large-cap funds already trading sell calls to help pay for their puts, which gives up some of the gain if stocks rise. All three charge less than this fund. The total annual fee is 0.70%.

Brandywine keeps that upside in the design. A futures portfolio is meant to earn the cost of the puts back. The firm has never managed an ETF.

A put is a contract that gains value if an index falls below a set price. These puts refer to an index Brandywine judges most closely tied to the stocks.

A face value of about 45% is not a promise that 45% of an investor's money is protected. The puts start to pay only after the index falls below a price set beneath the market. The fund seeks protection that generally matches that face value, not a floor under the whole investment.

The fund can still take significant losses with the hedge in place. The cost of the puts comes out of returns, particularly if the options expire worthless.

Brandywine's page, as of Nov. 13, names the S&P 500 Total Return Index as the benchmark. The prospectus lets the adviser choose another widely recognized large-cap index for the ETFs it buys and for the puts, so long as at least 80% of that index, by market value, is in large U.S. stocks.

The stock holding, mostly other ETFs that own U.S. companies of $10 billion or more, is meant to match the size of the fund. The puts sit on top of that holding.

A separate futures portfolio is there to earn the cost back. It uses about three dozen quantitative approaches across more than 100 markets in currencies, interest rates, stock indexes and commodities.

The filing says there is no assurance it will cover that cost. The portfolio can lose money whether markets rise or fall.

What it costs next to funds already trading

Simplify's Simplify Hedged Equity ETF HEQT, JPMorgan Asset Management's JPMorgan Hedged Equity Laddered Overlay ETF HELO and Morgan Stanley's Parametric Hedged Equity ETF PHEQ sell calls to help pay for their puts. Selling the calls is how those funds give up some of a rising market.

HEQT's Nov. 1 summary prospectus says that structure tends to cost less than only buying puts. The hedge applies to up to 20% of the fund.

HELO's Oct. 31 fact sheet says writing the options limits the gain if stocks rise. PHEQ's Jan. 28 summary prospectus says the sold calls are meant to offset the cost of the puts, and that they cut the gain above a set price.

Overlay Shares' Overlay Shares Hedged Large Cap Equity ETF OVLH is the closer match. Its Dec. 31, 2025 summary prospectus says the fund buys long-term puts with a face value generally near the whole fund.

FundProtectionTotal annual expensesAssets
Brandywine Large Cap ETF BWLBBuys puts on about 45% of the fund. A futures portfolio is meant to cover the cost.0.70%$29.5 million
Simplify Hedged Equity ETF HEQTSells calls on up to 20% of the fund to help pay for puts0.48%$308 million
JPMorgan Hedged Equity Laddered Overlay ETF HELOSells calls to help pay for puts0.50%$4.85 billion
Parametric Hedged Equity ETF PHEQSells calls to help pay for puts0.29%$149 million
Overlay Shares Hedged Large Cap Equity ETF OVLHBuys puts with a face value near the whole fund0.80%$103 million

Assets are as of Nov. 13, except PHEQ on Nov. 6 and HELO on Oct. 31. Brandywine's fee is higher than the three call-selling funds and lower than OVLH, which seeks a larger hedge.

The prospectus fee table is a 0.68% management fee plus an estimated 0.02% for the ETFs held inside, which is the 0.70% total. Brandywine's page showed 0.68% as of Nov. 13, "per the current prospectus," and said there is no fee waiver.

The adviser pays ordinary operating costs, but not the fees of the funds held inside. That is why the page and the total differ.

A plain large-cap fund does not charge for puts it does not buy. This one charges for a partial hedge and a futures portfolio that may not earn that cost back. It has no track record.

Who runs the fund

Michael P. Dever founded Brandywine in 1982. He and Matthew M. Dever manage the fund. The prospectus puts it this way.

"The Adviser has no experience with managing an ETF, which may limit the Adviser's effectiveness."

Brandywine is registered as a commodity-pool operator, the registration that covers the futures. The filing says that operator has not managed accounts or pools with objectives and strategies substantially similar to this fund's.

The adviser is in three lawsuits, none involving the fund. One, filed in April, claims breach of contract over the purchase price of an investment fund. Two, filed in July and arising from a closed hedge fund, claim fraud and breach of fiduciary duty.

Brandywine says it has meritorious defenses and intends to defend the cases vigorously. An adverse result could affect the firm's ability to keep advising the fund. The filing says that could mean a new adviser, or closing the fund.

Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google

ETFs in this story

BHEQTSimplify Hedged Equity ETF62/100AHELOJPMorgan Hedged Equity Laddered Overlay ETF71/100APHEQParametric Hedged Equity ETF71/100BOVLHOverlay Shares Hedged Large Cap Equity ETF54/100

Related articles