Skip to content

MarketsDeep Dive

JEPI vs. a 60/40 fund: It won over five years only because of 2022.

JPMorgan’s $46 billion income ETF beat a 60/40 stock-and-bond fund over the five years through Sept. 30, 2026, because of its 2022 results alone. Over the past three years it trailed that fund by about 4.5 percentage points a year, with nearly the same volatility.

·

Over-the-shoulder view of a person reviewing printed financial charts and analyzing market data on a laptop.

Key takeaways

  • JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF beat a 60/40 balanced fund over five years largely because of 2022.
  • Over the past three years JEPI trailed the iShares 60/40 fund by about 4.5 points a year.
  • JEPI was barely calmer than the balanced fund, with three-year volatility of 7.80% against 8.21%.
  • JEPI's roughly 8% payout rises when markets are fearful and shrinks when they calm.
  • Because note income is taxed as ordinary income, the payout costs more in a taxable account.

Hamilton Reiner, lead portfolio manager of the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI), calls the fund a 60/40 portfolio without the bonds. He made that pitch to Paperjam in April, a Luxembourg business outlet, during an April 2026 European tour to promote an Irish-domiciled version of the fund.

JEPI was never built to keep up with the S&P 500, so the fair test is the one Reiner proposes: whether an all-stock fund that sells away part of its upside has behaved like a classic mix of 60% stocks and 40% bonds while paying far more income. Over five years the answer is roughly yes. Over the past three it is no, and the fund was barely calmer than the balanced fund it is pitched to replace.

JEPI owns defensive U.S. stocks plus a slice of bank-issued option notes

JEPI has two parts. The larger is an actively managed portfolio of U.S. large-cap stocks that JPMorgan's fund page says are picked through bottom-up research for "less volatile earnings and share prices." The fund tracks no index; the S&P 500 is its benchmark and the market its options are written on.

The smaller part, typically about 15% of the portfolio by Morningstar analyst Brendan McCann's account, produces most of the income. Rather than sell call options itself, the fund buys equity-linked notes (ELNs): bank-issued securities that pay it the returns of a covered-call strategy on the S&P 500. Selling a call brings in cash now in exchange for giving up gains above a set level, so the notes trade upside for income.

The stock portfolio is widely spread: in holdings data for Nov. 16, 2026, it held 118 stocks, the largest was Mastercard at 2.0%, and the 10 biggest positions together came to 18.9%. McCann notes that peers tend to hold more technology, "so this fund can especially lag in tech-led rallies."

JEPI is light on technology versus the S&P 500

Sector weights for JEPI and SPY, Nov. 16, 2026

  • JEPI
  • S&P 500
  • Technology
    • JEPI 19.5%
    • S&P 500 36.1%
  • Industrials
    • JEPI 14%
    • S&P 500 8.2%
  • Cons. defensive
    • JEPI 10.4%
    • S&P 500 5.1%
  • Utilities
    • JEPI 5.7%
    • S&P 500 2.1%

Industrials, consumer defensive and utilities are the offsets.

The fund charges 0.35% a year, held $45.3 billion at Sept. 30, according to JPMorgan, and trades about $297 million of shares a day. etf.net grades it an A, first of 19 funds in its S&P 500 active option income category, judged only against peers making the same promise.

JEPI beat a 60/40 fund over five years only because of 2022

The obvious balanced comparison is the iShares Core 60/40 Balanced Allocation ETF, AOR. The match is imperfect, because AOR holds global stocks and bonds through index funds while JEPI owns only U.S. stocks.

Period to Sept. 30, 2026JPMorgan Equity Premium Income JEPIiShares Core 60/40 Balanced Allocation AORS&P 500
1 year6.62%9.32%15.74%
3 years10.05%14.53%22.89%
5 years7.78%6.92%13.79%

Sources: JPMorgan fact sheet; iShares.

The five-year lead over AOR comes almost entirely from one year. In 2022, when stocks and bonds fell together, JEPI lost 3.54%, compared with 15.30% for the balanced fund and 18.11% for the S&P 500. Over the three years to Sept. 30, 2026, it trailed the balanced fund by about 4.5 percentage points a year; by calendar year, it was behind in 2023 and 2025 and ahead in 2024.

AOR paid far less income. Its 30-day SEC yield was 2.63% on Oct. 31, 2026, against 7.06% for JEPI. Even so, AOR returned about 4.5 percentage points a year more over the three years through Sept. 30, 2026, because its share price rose enough to more than make up for its smaller payouts.

JPMorgan's fact sheet dated Oct. 31, 2026, puts the fund's three-year volatility, the standard deviation of its monthly returns, at 7.80%, against 12.31% for the S&P 500. iShares puts AOR at 8.21% over the three years to Oct. 31. So the income fund was barely smoother than the balanced fund while returning less. JPMorgan also puts JEPI’s three-year beta at 0.40, meaning the fund moved about 0.4% on average for each 1% move in the S&P 500. Its beta looks more defensive than the volatility figures because it also reflects correlation, and JEPI’s returns do not move in lockstep with the index’s.

In October 2026, the S&P 500 lost 0.87% and JEPI returned 3.05% at net asset value, a gap of almost 4 percentage points. Option income can explain little of that gap, because JEPI’s entire monthly payout has lately run at about 0.6% of its share price. Technology stocks, which make up a much smaller share of JEPI than of the index, fell that month. The Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund, XLK, for example, lost 8.3%, including dividends.

JEPI’s payout rises and falls with market volatility.

JEPI paid $4.56 a share over the 12 months through its Nov. 2 distribution, a trailing yield of 8.06% at the Nov. 17, 2026, afternoon price of about $56.61. The figure to plan around is JPMorgan's 30-day SEC yield, a standardized measure of recent income, at 7.06% on Oct. 31, because it reflects what the fund earns now rather than a year that included richer months.

Calls cost more when markets are turbulent; in JPMorgan's words, "as volatility increases, the potential for incremental income and upside also increases." The April 2025 tariff sell-off showed how quickly the payout can rise and fall. The VIX, an index of expected stock market volatility that Cboe calculates from S&P 500 option prices, closed at 52.33 on April 8, 2025, its highest close since 2020. JEPI paid $0.41 a share in early April, before the sell-off, $0.54 in June and $0.36 in August.

This November's $0.35 was 43% below the $0.61 paid in November 2022, during that year's bear market.

The share price, meanwhile, is 6.9% lower than five years ago and roughly flat this year, so nearly all of the fund's return has come through distributions. An owner who spends every payment is consuming the return rather than building capital: a sensible choice for some retirees, a poor one for anyone who still needs the portfolio to grow.

Taxes favor holding JEPI in a retirement account

The notes make the payout expensive in a taxable account. McCann writes that income from these notes "is taxed as ordinary income, making the strategy less tax-efficient than selling calls directly." In 2025 only 15.86% of the fund's ordinary dividends qualified for the lower dividend tax rate. At the top federal rates in JPMorgan's own retirement guide, 40.8% on ordinary income and 23.8% on qualified dividends with the 3.8% net investment income tax, that mix works out to about 38%, cutting an 8.06% yield to roughly 5% after tax.

By our reckoning, an investor in the 24% bracket who pays 15% on qualified dividends and no investment income tax would keep about 6.2%.

Some rivals sell index options directly, and their distributions can be taxed differently. Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF, GPIX, charges 0.29% under a fee waiver that runs to April 2027 and holds the whole index rather than a defensive selection. Goldman estimated that 91.3% of GPIX's distributions this fiscal year through Oct. 31 were return of capital. Return of capital isn’t taxed when paid; it lowers the shareholder’s cost basis, which raises the taxable gain when the shares are sold. The final split appears on Form 1099-DIV and can differ from Goldman’s monthly estimates.

GPIX has also kept far more of the market's gains. In 2025 it returned 16.39% at net asset value, Goldman reported, close to the S&P 500's 17.88%; JPMorgan's fact sheet shows 8.07% for JEPI. The catch is that GPIX launched in October 2023, so it has no record from a year like 2022, and no defensive stock selection to lean on in one.

Investors in Europe can buy the Irish-domiciled UCITS version Reiner was promoting in April, to which these U.S. tax points do not apply.

JEPI suits income seekers in tax-deferred accounts, not growth investors

JEPI fits an investor who wants a large monthly payment from stocks, accepts that it will vary, and values smaller losses in a crash over keeping up with the market, ideally inside a retirement account such as an IRA. For that investor it is a well-run, liquid way to own the strategy, and nothing in its category is both cheaper and close to its size.

It is a poor fit for someone whose main goal is long-term growth, because over the past three years an actual 60/40 fund did better with similar volatility. AOR costs 0.15% under a fee waiver iShares filed through Nov. 30, 2026, though it yields only about 2.6%. Nor does JEPI suit a high-bracket investor holding it in a taxable account who does not need the cash; for that investor, McCann suggests that selling shares with long-term gains can be a more tax-efficient way to raise income.

A current holder thinking about switching should first calculate the capital-gains tax a sale would trigger. Two things are worth watching:

The first is the monthly payment. Twelve payments of November’s $0.35 would total $4.20 a share, a 7.4% yield at the Nov. 17, 2026, price, below the 8.06% trailing yield. The second is its showing in the next sharp sell-off, the kind of market in which it has earned its keep and the 60/40 comparison has tipped its way.

Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google

ETFs in this story

AJEPIJPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF78/100AGPIXGoldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF78/100AAORiShares Core 60/40 Balanced Allocation ETF81/100AXLKState Street Technology Select Sector SPDR ETF82/100

Related articles