Skip to content

MarketsDeep Dive

Oil ETFs holding near-month crude nearly doubled in a year of war with Iran. Now the IEA sees a surplus

Funds holding the nearest crude contracts gained as much as 98% in a year as their 12-month and gas siblings lagged, and with supply returning, construction matters again.

·

An aerial view of a sprawling oil refinery with smoking chimneys under a dramatic sunset sky.

Key takeaways

  • The United States Oil Fund gained 90.5% in a year by holding near-month crude during the war.
  • Its sibling, the United States 12 Month Oil Fund, rose 58.3% because it owned later, cheaper months.
  • With the IEA now seeing a surplus, USO has fallen 18.5% from its October high.
  • The war pushed U.S. gas prices down, and the United States Natural Gas Fund lost 27.8%.
  • ProShares K-1 Free Crude Oil ETF ranks first on fees and taxes despite trailing this year's biggest winners.

On Nov. 13, the International Energy Agency (IEA) said global oil supply was exceeding demand for the first time since the war in Iran began. By the close on Nov. 19, USCF's United States Oil Fund USO, the largest fund in etf.net's Energy Futures category, sat 18.5% below its Oct. 23 closing high. It was still up 90.5% from a year earlier.

Its sibling, the United States 12 Month Oil Fund USL, comes from the same issuer and tracks the same crude, U.S. light sweet oil delivered at Cushing, Oklahoma. It rose 58.3%. Much of that 32-percentage-point gap comes from which months of oil each fund owns, and the same construction now shapes what holders keep as the market turns.

USO is still up 90.5%, 18.5% below its October high

Nov. 18, 2025–Nov. 19, 2026 closes; USO vs its Oct. 23 high.

USO, 1-year
+90.5%
USO vs Oct. 23 high
−18.5%
USL, 1-year
+58.3%

USL, which spreads WTI across 12 months, rose 58.3%.

The war made oil for delivery now worth far more than oil for later

U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran began on Feb. 28, according to the Congressional Research Service, and Iran answered by attacking shipping in the Strait of Hormuz. The IEA says North Sea Dated, the price of physical crude cargoes loading now, peaked at $136 a barrel on Oct. 8 and had fallen to about $93 by its November report.

This year, contracts for near delivery have traded far above those for later months, a shape called backwardation. Futures expire, so a fund must keep selling the contract about to expire and buying the next one, which is called rolling. A fund that rolls $100 oil into $99 oil "would be able to buy more contracts than it originally had," Fidelity notes. In contango, where later months cost more, the same roll buys fewer.

Erik Norland, an economist at CME Group, calculated in July that a position in front-month futures on West Texas Intermediate (WTI), the U.S. crude USO holds, rolled before each expiry, had gained 84% since the start of the year, and that rolling had added 27% to that return beyond what the change in the front-month price delivered.

USO holds the front of the curve; USL spreads its money equally across 12 consecutive months. On Nov. 19, the January 2027 WTI contract, USO's front month, closed at $82.44, and December 2027, the last month in USL, closed at $72.18, a gap of $10.26 a barrel. USL owned a year of more distant barrels that never repriced as much as the front, and it charges 1.01% a year against USO's 0.86%.

Supply is returning, and the front-month fund is giving back the most

The IEA says Gulf crude exports recovered to 82% of their prewar level in October, and it expects a surplus this quarter. "For the first time since the US-Iran conflict began, traders are actively contemplating the possibility of excess supply rather than persistent tightness," Tim Waterer, chief analyst at KCM Trade, told Reuters on Nov. 16.

USO fell 13.6% in the month through Nov. 19, against 11.5% for USL. The fighting goes on: Iran's attacks on tankers increased in October and kept that pace this month, Bloomberg reported.

USO falls when front-month WTI falls. While the curve stays backwardated, each roll still buys a little more oil, but a narrower gap adds less. "Backwardation can strengthen, weaken, collapse completely or even flip back into contango," Norland wrote. "As such the roll yields apparent in today's price can change quickly."

USL also trades far less: about $660,000 of shares a day on average over the 20 sessions through Nov. 19, against about $756 million for USO. For a seller that can mean a worse price: thinly traded ETFs "can be harder to sell and may have larger bid-ask spreads," the Securities and Exchange Commission warns.

The same war pushed U.S. gas down, and UNG with it

USCF's United States Natural Gas Fund UNG lost 27.8% over the year, even as Europe's benchmark gas price more than doubled between February and October, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) outlook.

But UNG tracks Henry Hub in Louisiana, and the war pushed that price the other way. Wood Mackenzie explains why: high oil prices drove production growth in the U.S. Lower 48, which brought "huge amounts of additional associated gas from oil drilling, pushing down benchmark Henry Hub prices." The EIA expects Henry Hub to average $2.87 from November through March, 36% less than last winter.

Its sibling, the United States 12 Month Natural Gas Fund UNL, spreads its money across 12 months, charges 1.65% and fell further, 33.9%.

Oil's war-year winners are the ones giving back

Price returns through Nov. 19, 2026. 1-year from Nov. 18, 2025 close; 1-month from Oct. 21, 2026 close.

USO at +90.5%, −13.6%; USL at +58.3%, −11.5%; UNG at −27.8%, +2.9%; UNL at −33.9%, +0.4%0.0%0.0%USOUSLUNGUNL1-year return1-month return

Henry Hub funds were flat to up as WTI sold off.

Why the top-graded oil funds were not this year's biggest winners

etf.net grades each fund against its category, here 11 Energy Futures funds, on fee, behavior when markets fell, ease of trading, holdings disclosure, and age and size. It does not reward gains as such. So USCF's United States Brent Oil Fund BNO, up 98%, earns a C, while ProShares K-1 Free Crude Oil ETF OILK, up 62.4%, ranks first with an A. OILK's 0.70% fee is the category's lowest; BNO charges 1.15%.

OILK is also built differently. Its index, as ProShares describes it, splits WTI into thirds: one rolls monthly, one each June and one each December. Its share price rose 26% over the year, and it paid out $14.17 a share, about 36% of its starting price; together those make up its 62.4% total return. ProShares notes that funds like OILK must distribute substantially all their income and capital gains at least annually.

In exchange, OILK holders get a 1099 tax form, the point of the fund's name. ProShares says the alternative, the Schedule K-1, brings "additional complexities, including tax filing delays." USO, USL, BNO, UNG and UNL issue K-1s, USCF says, as do Invesco's DB funds, and Invesco warns their holders can owe tax on unsold gains because the futures are treated as sold at year-end value.

The Invesco DB Energy Fund DBE, second with an A, doesn't just hold the front month: its quarterly filing says it picks contracts to soften the drag of contango and make the most of backwardation. At Sept. 30, about 62% of its basket by value was crude and 27% diesel-type fuels, with gasoline and natural gas making up the rest. Its sibling, the Invesco DB Oil Fund DBO, holds only WTI and picks the contract with the highest implied roll yield.

FundWhat it holdsNet fee1-year total returnGrade
BNONearest Brent contract1.15%98.0%C
USONearest WTI contract0.86%90.5%B
DBECrude, fuel and gas basket0.74%81.3%A
DBOWTI, chosen by roll yield0.81%76.1%B
OILKWTI on three roll schedules0.70%62.4%A
USLWTI, 12 months equally1.01%58.3%C
UNGNearest Henry Hub gas contract1.17%−27.8%D
UNLHenry Hub gas, 12 months equally1.65%−33.9%F

Returns from the Nov. 18, 2025 close to the Nov. 19, 2026 close, including distributions.

A tanker-freight fund shows how fast the war trade can reverse

Amplify's Breakwave Tanker Shipping ETF BWET holds no fuel, only futures on the cost of shipping crude. BWET rose 3,410% over the year, then fell 47% from its Oct. 8 closing high to Nov. 10 before gaining 27% in the five sessions through Nov. 19.

Emergency diesel and a possible Hormuz deal are next for the oil curve

The IEA plans to make 71 million barrels from its members' emergency stocks available by the end of February, including 15 million barrels of diesel, Reuters reported. Diesel-type fuels made up 27% of DBE's basket at Sept. 30.

The research firm BMI expects a preliminary deal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz in the first quarter of 2027. "In turn, regional crude exports will stabilise, eclipsing pre-conflict levels as production grows," its analysts wrote in a client note cited by Reuters.

For holders, the number to watch is the gap between USO's front month and the last month in USL, $10.26 a barrel on Nov. 19. While it stays wide, USO's rolls keep buying more oil; if it closes or flips into contango, as Norland warned it can, that edge disappears and the roll starts costing the front-month fund.

Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google

ETFs in this story

BUSOUnited States Oil Fund, LP62/100CUSLUnited States 12 Month Oil Fund51/100AOILKProShares K-1 Free Crude Oil ETF79/100DUNGUnited States Natural Gas Fund LP31/100CBNOUnited States Brent Oil Fund LP42/100

Related articles