Skip to content

MarketsIncome Watch

SPYI's 13% yield didn't shield holders, who lost 7.9% in a week the S&P 500 fell 8.6%

NEOS estimates 96% of the fund's November check was return of capital, and Roundhill puts all of its daily-options fund's latest weekly payment in that column.

A digital trading chart displays a sharp red downward trend line against a dark background.

Key takeaways

  • NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF holders lost 7.9% in a week the S&P 500 fell 8.6%.
  • NEOS estimates 96% of the fund's November payment was return of capital, not investment income.
  • Roundhill's daily-options fund's 31.85% trailing yield depends on two large December 2025 year-end payouts.
  • Leaving out year-end payments, Roundhill's regular payout over the past 12 months fell 37% from the year before.
  • Invesco S&P 500 BuyWrite ETF estimates a $0.91 year-end payout, more than triple 2025's capital-gain payment.

The S&P 500 fell 8.6% in the five sessions to Nov. 20, stocks' worst week in more than a year, as concerns about the sustainability of the artificial-intelligence boom "boiled over," The New York Times reported. Funds that sell options on the index to pay large checks kept paying, and the checks barely softened the blow.

NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF SPYI, which sells call options on the S&P 500, paid $0.516 a share on Nov. 20, slightly more than October's $0.5087. Its share price fell 8.9% on the week, a little more than the index. Counting the payment, holders lost 7.9%, against 8.6% for SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust SPY, which paid nothing that week.

SPYI ended the week at 91.14, just under SPY

Daily closes rebased to 100 at Nov. 13, 2026

SPYI ended the week at 91.14, just under SPY: SPYI from 100 to 91.14; SPY from 100 to 91.44. Use the arrow keys to read each point.
Nov. 1320
  • SPYI · 91.14
  • SPY · 91.44

Friday took SPYI from 94.42 to 91.14.

NEOS estimates 96% of SPYI's payment is return of capital

A Section 19(a) notice, required under federal rules, estimates where a payment came from. NEOS's November notice puts $0.4961 of the $0.516, or 96%, down as return of capital and just $0.0199 as net investment income. The same 96% applies to the $5.785 paid across the 11 payments of 2026. These are estimates; the final tax split arrives on Form 1099-DIV.

Is that bad for the holder? Roundhill's prospectus for XDTE, below, sets out the trade: a return of capital "generally will not be taxable but will reduce the shareholder's cost basis," leaving a larger gain or smaller loss to be taxed when the shares are sold.

Total return is the better test of what holders keep. SPYI's last 12 monthly payments add up to $6.32 a share, a trailing yield of 13.2% on Friday's $47.83 close. Over the year from Nov. 19, 2025, its price fell 7.4%; with payments reinvested, holders made 5.4%, against 5.2% for SPY. Over three years SPYI returned 45.6% with payments reinvested, behind SPY's 59.1%. It charges 0.68% a year.

XDTE's 31.85% yield leans on $3.43 of December 2025 payouts

Roundhill S&P 500 0DTE Covered Call Strategy ETF XDTE sells S&P 500 call options with "zero days to expiration," the 0DTE of its name, every business day, its annual report says, and pays weekly. The latest payment, $0.14023 a share with a Nov. 19 ex-date, was 48% below the $0.26888 paid a year earlier. Roundhill's 19(a) notice estimates all of it as return of capital.

Its last 52 payments total $10.89, a trailing yield of 31.85% on Friday's $34.18 close. Two December 2025 payments, $1.38 (ex-date Dec. 24) and $2.05 (ex-date Dec. 31), make up $3.43 of that; without them the yield is about 21.8%. Roundhill's notices at the time estimated both as entirely net investment income, and the fund paid larger year-end checks in December 2024 too, $0.64 and $0.61. Roundhill's financial statements say the fund distributes any net capital gains at least annually and that its funds "may also pay a special distribution at the end of the calendar year to comply with Federal tax requirements." Take both years' year-end payments out, and the regular payout over the past 12 months is down 37% from the 12 before.

Over the year from Nov. 19, 2025, XDTE's price fell 20%. With payments reinvested, holders made 5.4%, level with SPYI.

XDTE went from a 20.2% price loss to a 5.4% total return

Price and total return, Nov. 19, 2025–Nov. 20, 2026

XDTE −20.2% → +5.4%; SPYI −7.4% → +5.4%; SPY +4.1% → +5.2%PriceTotal returnXDTE · −20.2%+5.4% · XDTESPYI · −7.4%+5.4% · SPYISPY · +4.1%

SPYI rose from -7.4% to +5.4%; SPY from +4.1% to +5.2%.

J.P. Morgan says volatility tends to lift option income

Option-income funds "typically generate more income" in volatile periods "because options' prices are positively correlated to volatility," J.P. Morgan Asset Management wrote on Nov. 17. The Cboe Volatility Index, Wall Street's gauge of expected swings, closed Friday at 35.89. That income cushions a fall only partly: it "can partially offset the loss," but covered calls "do not remove market risk," Global X's Marc Jocum wrote this month.

PBP's estimated $0.91 year-end payout is more than triple 2025's

Invesco S&P 500 BuyWrite ETF PBP expects to pay a capital-gain distribution of $0.91 a share, about 3.95% of net asset value, Invesco estimates: $0.61 of short-term gains and $0.30 of long-term. In December 2025 it paid $0.27931 in capital gains. The figures are as of Oct. 30, and Invesco says they "will change."

YieldMax's Thanksgiving dates differ from WeeklyYield's calendar

WeeklyYield's calendar projects a Nov. 26 ex-date and Nov. 27 payment for YieldMax AMD Option Income Strategy ETF AMDY and YieldMax COIN Option Income Strategy ETF CONY. Both are in YieldMax's Group 2, which its own schedule has going ex-dividend Nov. 27 and paying Nov. 30; Group 1 funds go ex Nov. 25 and pay Nov. 27. YieldMax says its distribution rates "may not be sustainable."

The next dates: Dec. 1 for IBMO, Dec. 16 for SPYI, Dec. 21 for PBP

iShares iBonds Dec 2026 Term Muni Bond ETF IBMO, a fund built to close on a set date, trades for the last time Dec. 1, its SEC supplement says. Proceeds, net of liquidation costs, are scheduled to go out Dec. 4. SPYI's next ex-date is Dec. 16, with payment Dec. 18, on NEOS's schedule; the amount isn't set.

Then comes PBP, with an ex-date and record date of Dec. 21 and payment Dec. 28. For anyone weighing the fund before that estimated $0.91, the ex-date is the line: shares bought on or after it don't carry the payment.

Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google

ETFs in this story

ASPYINeos S&P 500(R) High Income ETF72/100CXDTERoundhill S&P 500 0DTE Covered Call Strategy ETF40/100APBPInvesco S&P 500 BuyWrite ETF69/100ASPYState Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF69/100BAMDYYieldMax AMD Option Income Strategy ETF54/100

Related articles