BlackRock's BAI, largest of etf.net's AI funds, trails the S&P 500 for the year as sister fund ARTY gains 30%
The median AI fund beat the market over 12 months, but what a holder kept depended on which part of the AI business the fund owned, and when.

Key takeaways
BlackRock's iShares A.I. Innovation and Tech Active ETF, BAI, is the largest of the 30 funds in etf.net's artificial intelligence category, with $11.6 billion in assets. Over the 12 months through Thursday, Nov. 19, it returned 3.1% with dividends reinvested, against 9.2% for the State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF SPY. BlackRock's passive iShares Future AI & Tech ETF, ARTY, returned 29.9%.
The theme itself paid: the median fund in the category returned about 14%. But the 27-percentage-point gap between two BlackRock funds sold under one label is what the year established: returns turned on which part of the AI business a fund owned, and when. One of BAI's largest holdings is now Anthropic, which listed on Thursday.
Chips carried the first half and sank the third quarter
BAI is actively managed, and at the end of September its five largest holdings were Micron, AMD, Nvidia, Taiwan Semiconductor and Broadcom. ARTY tracks the Morningstar Global Artificial Intelligence Select Index: 51 companies, about 42% of the fund in the top 10, with names such as Oracle, Naver, IBM and Palantir alongside many of the same chipmakers.
The PHLX Semiconductor index was up 107% for the year at its June peak, iShares strategists Jay Jacobs and Kristy Akullian wrote, and BAI peaked on June 22. In the third quarter, Morningstar's Katherine Wu reported that a Morningstar software index rose 25% in July and August while its semiconductor index fell 4%. BAI's share price fell 10.5% in the quarter while ARTY's rose 2.8%. The category's median fund lost about 0.9%; SPY returned 2.4%.
Since September, BAI and ARTY have fallen about four times as far as the S&P 500
From the Sept. 30 close through Thursday, BAI's share price fell 28.3% and ARTY's 24.1%, against 6.1% for SPY.
Democrats won both houses of Congress on Nov. 3, and two days later the Nasdaq fell 6%, its worst day since March 2020. Jacobs and Akullian named the data-center risks: voters in 41 local ballot measures favored restricting new data centers, and Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has called for a pause on new approvals and an end to data-center tax incentives. Texas holds about 30% of planned U.S. data-center projects for 2028, they wrote.
BlackRock's technology team cut its 2028 estimate of new data-center capacity outside China from about 66 gigawatts to 62, a 6% reduction it called "more likely to be delayed than permanently lost." Jacobs and Akullian called it "a meaningful adjustment, particularly for companies whose valuations depend on rapid growth in AI infrastructure spending." Citing Morgan Stanley data showing the largest cut in hedge funds' stock exposure in more than 15 years, they argued the declines were "amplified by technicals rather than a broad retreat from AI by long-term investors."
On Nov. 12 Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia's chief executive after The New York Times reported extramarital affairs, one with a woman U.S. intelligence officials believed was spying for China. Lawmakers from both parties are pushing for tighter curbs on AI chip sales to China, Reuters reported, and interim CEO Colette Kress said on the Nov. 17 earnings call that Nvidia is "no longer shipping licensed Hopper data center products to China." Nvidia's shares fell 28.7% in November through Thursday, when BAI closed 37.6% below its June peak and ARTY 26.8% below its Oct. 6 high.
Anthropic's debut made it one of BAI's largest holdings
Unlike an index fund, BAI can own private companies, and BlackRock has pitched it as a way to hold Anthropic and OpenAI before their IPOs. On June 2 they were 0.67% and 0.29% of the fund.
Anthropic priced its IPO at $83 a share, opened on Nasdaq at $111.50 on Thursday and closed at $97.17. In BAI's latest holdings file, listed Anthropic shares valued at that close are 5.2% of the fund, its fifth-largest position, plus 1.4% in unlisted Anthropic lines; SpaceX, listed in June, is another 4.3%. Nvidia, third at the end of September, is now 14th. By 10:27 a.m. ET Friday Anthropic was down 11.5% at $85.99, enough alone to take about 0.6 percentage point off BAI, which was down 6.8%.
Five of the 11 biggest AI funds trailed the S&P 500 over 12 months
On a price basis the VistaShares Artificial Intelligence Supercycle ETF AIS gained 36%, the category's best; etf.net found in August that Micron alone had supplied about 17 percentage points of its gain that year. The Themes Generative Artificial Intelligence ETF WISE lost 32%. Five of the 11 largest funds, BAI among them, trailed SPY.
12-month returns of the 11 largest AI funds
Over the six months through Thursday, BAI's share price fell 28.8% and ARTY's 12.7%, while SPY's slipped 3.6%. Morningstar ETF research director Bryan Armour warned in October that "price matters" with AI funds. "There's so much projection in valuing AI companies," he said, "that it makes it really hard to know whether you're still coming in before the full wave or if you're buying in on the crest."
Fees, 0.47% a year for ARTY and 0.55% after a waiver for BAI, are small next to those spreads. For anyone choosing an AI fund, the year's lesson is to read the top 10 holdings before the fund's name. Two AI ETFs from the same issuer ended 12 months 27 percentage points apart, and one of them now counts among its largest positions a stock that has traded for two days.
Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google
ETFs in this story
Related articles
Category Review
International active ETFs trail the S&P 500 in 2026, but the cheapest funds still beat the category median

Category Review
XLE gained 44.5% this year on the Iran war's oil shock, while pipeline ETFs made about half as much

Category Review
Investment-grade corporate bond ETFs lost money this year on rising interest rates, not on corporate credit
