Skip to content

MarketsDeep Dive

Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF's Set to Gain More Than Current Cash Yield Suggests

BND's 4.1% cash dividend yield is below its 5.08% SEC yield because much of its expected return comes from discounted bonds climbing back to face value. That shows up in NAV, not cash dividends.

·

A person's hand counts US dollar bills over a desk covered in financial performance charts.

Key takeaways

  • Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF's monthly check is cash, not the yield on its bonds.
  • Vanguard's 5.08% SEC yield is hypothetical and can differ from the cash actually paid.
  • The five-year return stays negative because the price drop in 2022 is still included.
  • Its cash yields sit closer to the 3.9% coupon than to yield to maturity.
  • The 0.03% fee is not what separates the cash yields from the SEC yield.

Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF (BND) paid about $2.94 a share in dividends over the past 12 months, a 4.12% yield on its Oct. 26 close of $71.27. But its 30-day SEC yield, in contrast, was 5.08% as of Oct. 23.

That's because most of the bonds in the fund's portfolio are currently trading at a discount to their face values. Their prices increase as they approach maturity, but this price appreciation doesn't show up in cash dividends. Instead, this component of total returns shows up in share prices. The SEC yield captures this price appreciation, in addition to the cash dividend yield - hence the difference between the two numbers.

Context: The current bond selloff

Bond funds are in the doghouse this year. Yields are up in 2026 as the Federal Reserve raised its target rate, and the 10-year Treasury yield reached 5.18% on Sept. 24, its highest in nearly 20 years, pushing bond prices to near 20-year lows.

And the Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF BND is doing exactly what it's designed to do: Lose money along with the Index. At least, as long as yields are rising.

BND performance

The Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Index, the broader version of BND’s benchmark, was down about 2.5% for the year through Sept. 24 as its yield rose about 1.2 percentage points. BND’s own yield to maturity climbed from 5.0% on Aug. 31 to 5.6% on Sept. 30. Through that date, BND's YTD returns were -0.82%, it's NAV return was down -1.82% over the trailing 12 months, and its market price was down 1.85% over the same time frame.

Over the five-year period ending Sept. 30, BND clocked an average annual return of 0.64% . That window includes the rate shock that began in late 2021 and lasted until the Aggregate Bond Index's yield reached about 5.7% in October 2023. It also includes this year’s sell-off.

In contrast, BDN's annualized trailing three-year return of 4% starts in Oct. 1, 2023, near the bottom for bond prices. So the trailing three year number begins from an unusually favorable point for U.S. bonds.

What is the 30-day SEC yield in bond ETFs?

On September 30, Vanguard put the portfolio's yield to maturity at 5.6% and the average coupon, the interest rate on the bonds, at 3.9%. Yield to maturity is the return if a bond is held to its maturity date. Vanguard's explanation says the figure considers the bond's price, its face value, the coupon and the time remaining.

The Securities and Exchange Commission yield starts from that same yield to maturity. Vanguard says it takes the bonds' yield to maturity over the prior 30 days and turns it into a hypothetical annualized income. As of October 23, Vanguard put that yield at 5.08%. Vanguard says the hypothetical can differ, at times significantly, from what the fund actually pays, so the distribution can be higher or lower than the SEC yield implies.

The October dividend was $0.248502 a share for investors who held the shares on October 1, paid on October 5. Vanguard's distribution yield on that payment was 4.25%. It annualizes the month's dividend, adjusting for the number of days in the month, and divides by the fund's average net asset value for the month.

The dividends from November 2025 through October 2026 were a 4.12% yield on the $71.27 close of Monday, October 26. Both of those cash yields sit closer to the 3.9% coupon rate than to the 5.6% yield to maturity.

The summary prospectus dated April 28, 2026 puts the expense ratio at 0.03%, or $3 a year on $10,000. Vanguard's fact sheet puts the average for core bond ETFs at 0.22%, using figures as of December 31, 2025.

The gap comes from the bonds’ prices, not from the fee. That's because most of the bonds in the portfolio are currently trading at a discount to their face value: They were issued when interest rates were significantly lower than they are today. The portfolio's average coupon rate is 3.9%. But the fund's average yield to maturity - the effective yield on bonds purchased today and held to maturity - is 5.6%.

Yield to maturity - and the SEC yield - count every bond's climb back to face value as return.

Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF (BND) paid about $2.94 a share in dividends over the past 12 months, equating to a 4.12% yield on Monday’s $71.27 close. But BND's 30-day SEC yield is 5.08%.

How can this be? The answer is in bond prices: Most of the bonds in BND's portfolio currently trade below face value. The higher SEC yield prices in their recovery as they approach maturity. But that price appreciation shows up in the share price, not the monthly cash dividend.

What does BND hold? Treasuries, mortgages, and corporate bonds

BND seeks to track the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Float Adjusted Index. As of September 30, the fact sheet describes the aim as broad exposure to the taxable investment-grade U.S. dollar-denominated bond market, excluding inflation-protected and tax-exempt bonds. Bloomberg's description on that sheet calls the index a measure of the investment-grade, dollar-denominated, fixed-rate taxable bond market.

Bloomberg's own description of the index says it reduces the amount outstanding of any position the U.S. Federal Reserve owns. That is what "float adjusted" means in the name.

The summary prospectus describes the index as public, investment-grade, taxable bonds with maturities of more than one year, including bonds priced in dollars from borrowers outside the United States.

On September 30, Treasuries and agencies were 49.4% of the portfolio. Government mortgage-backed securities were 19.1%. Industrial, finance and utility bonds together were 25.5%. Foreign issuers were 3.4%. The remainder was commercial mortgage bonds, asset-backed securities and other holdings.

Vanguard's credit-quality table is a separate cut from those issuer figures, and it runs down to CCC or lower. BBB bonds were 12.2%. The rows below BBB show nothing, and nothing was unrated.

The prospectus says borrowers repay mortgage-backed securities early more often when interest rates are low, and the fund then has to reinvest at a lower rate.

The bonds are spread across maturities. On September 30, 42.8% matured in one to five years and 36.0% in five to ten. Another 14.4% sat in the bands from 10 to 25 years, and 6.6% matured in more than 25. Bonds maturing in under a year were 0.2%.

The fund does not buy every bond in the index. The prospectus says it samples, holding a range of securities that together approximate the index in key risk factors, and keeps a dollar-weighted average maturity consistent with the index. On September 30 it held 11,434 bonds. The index had 14,254.

BND is the exchange-traded shares of Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund, not a separate portfolio. On September 30 BND had $161.4 billion. The fund as a whole had $389.3 billion.

Why is BND's 5-year return still negative?

Duration as a measure of how bond prices respond to interest-rate moves. A bond with a duration of 2 years would fall about 2% in price if interest rates rose 1 percentage point.

Average duration was 5.7 years on September 30, the same as the index, so that example puts the price drop at about 5.7% before income.

In 2022 BND's income did not cover the fall in bond prices. Vanguard's own return table splits that year's net-asset-value return into a capital loss of 15.20% and an income return of 2.06%. The total was a loss of 13.15%. closely replicating the benchmark index's loss of 13.07%.

Vanguard's income return was 4.08% in 2025, against 2.06% in 2022. In its annual report, Vanguard said that for the 12 months ended December 31, 2025, the fund performed in line with its benchmark. The report puts the net-asset-value return at 7.11% and the benchmark return at 7.21%.

On the fact sheet, the average annual net-asset-value return over the five years through September 30, 2026 was -0.64%. The index returned -0.62% a year over that stretch. Over three years the fund gained 4.04% a year. The five-year window still includes 2022. The three-year window does not.

Share price never recouped the 2022 drop

BND close, Sept. 30, 2021 to Sept. 30, 2026

Share price never recouped the 2022 drop: BND from $85.5 to $70.2. Use the arrow keys to read each point.2022
Sep 2021Sep 2026

Price only, dividends excluded, through Sept. 30, 2026.

Since the shares began on April 3, 2007, the average annual return on that sheet has been 2.86%. The benchmark in that comparison uses the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index through December 31, 2009, and the Float Adjusted Index after that. It returned 2.91% a year.

Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google

ETFs in this story

ABNDVanguard Total Bond Market ETF86/100

Related articles