BNY files for a commodity ETF co-managed by a portfolio manager of WisdomTree's commodity fund
The proposed BNY Commodity Strategy ETF would let computer models pick commodity futures, and one of its two managers already helps run a WisdomTree rival.

Key takeaways
BNY wants to sell a commodity fund under its own name, and one of the two people it has picked to run it already manages a competitor's commodity ETF. On Nov. 17, 2026, BNY Mellon ETF Trust II filed to add a new fund, the proposed BNY Commodity Strategy ETF. Its goal is "total return (consisting of capital appreciation and income)," and it would normally keep at least 80% of net assets in commodity-linked investments, mainly derivatives.
The filing names James Stavena and Louis Mangini of BNY Investments Corp., the proposed adviser, as portfolio managers. BNY's London-based affiliate Newton Investment Management Limited would provide "certain advisory services... including, but not limited to, portfolio management services."
Stavena runs multi-asset solutions, BNY's systematic investing group, according to his Newton biography. WisdomTree's latest prospectus lists him as a portfolio manager of the WisdomTree Enhanced Commodity Strategy Fund GCC since its inception in December 2020. He runs it with Torrey Zaches for the fund's sub-adviser, Newton Investment Management North America.
The BNY filing does not say whether Stavena would stay on GCC, and Newton North America still sub-advises that fund under a December 2025 agreement.
A model would pick the commodities, long and sometimes short
The proposed fund would not track an index, and the filing names no comparison index. The prospectus describes a "systematic, model-driven investment process" that reads commodity markets through relative value, economic conditions and price trends.
In practice, that means trading one commodity against another, using calendar spreads (positions on the gap between near-dated and later-dated futures on the same commodity) and adjusting as signals change. The menu runs from crude oil and gold to grains, livestock and softs, which the filing lists as coffee, cotton, cocoa and sugar.
The fund would be "primarily" long, meaning it would mostly hold positions that profit when prices rise, but it could also go short, profiting when prices fall, both to seek returns and to manage risk. The filing sets no numeric cap on shorts and warns that returns "may differ significantly" from commodity prices. Going short is not new in the category: the Neuberger Commodity Strategy ETF NBCM, run by Neuberger Berman, already seeks "long and short exposure."
The futures would sit mainly in a wholly owned Cayman Islands subsidiary, capped at 25% of assets at each quarter-end. The reason is tax. To avoid paying corporate tax, a fund must earn at least 90% of its income from sources the tax code counts as qualifying, and commodity gains do not count, the filing says. Income from the subsidiary does under current regulations, though the filing warns the IRS "might take the position" that it does not, which could cost the fund that status.
GCC has beaten its index over three and five years, though not since launch
GCC is the nearest public record of Stavena's work in an ETF, with one difference in mandate: it can put up to 10% of net assets in bitcoin funds and bitcoin futures. WisdomTree's fact sheet shows GCC's NAV, the value of its holdings per share, returned 13.1% a year over the five years to Sept. 30, ahead of the Bloomberg Commodity Index Total Return's 11.3%. Over three years it returned 19.2% a year against 15.6%.
Since its launch, though, GCC has returned 14.6% a year, slightly behind the index's 14.8%, and over the latest year it gained 33.2% against the index's 40.6%. Its assets were $194.1 million on Nov. 13, according to WisdomTree, against $334.1 million at the end of September. In between, GCC paid a distribution of $6.45 a share, which WisdomTree called "substantial."
GCC's share price fell 30% from Sept. 30 to Nov. 13
Newer active commodity funds have drawn little money
BNY would join a field where fees and size vary widely. The two newest active funds, Harbor's ACOM and Global X's COMD, both launched this year and hold just $6.1 million and $4.0 million, even as the Bloomberg Commodity Index Total Return gained 40.6% in the year to Sept. 30, according to GCC's fact sheet.
Lois Gregson, a senior ETF analyst at FactSet, wrote on Nov. 6 that actively managed commodity ETFs "remain more of a niche segment."
BNY's fee line is still blank, so where the new fund would sit in that table is unknown. Potential holders of the new commodity fund and current holders of GCC have a more pressing detail to consider, however: whether BNY's final prospectus or WisdomTree's next one changes who runs their fund.
Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google



