SPY vs. SPYM, VOO, and IVV: Why SPY trails cheaper S&P 500 ETFs
SPY holds dividends in cash until its quarterly payout - potentially causing drag on returns. It cannot lend its stocks to earn extra income. Over the year through Sept. 30, 2026, it trailed the S&P 500 by 0.14 percentage point, more than three cheaper funds that track the same index.

Key takeaways
State Street SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY), charges 0.0945% a year, or $9.45 on $10,000 invested. Bit the fund trails the index by more than its fee. Over the 10 years through Sept. 30, 2026, its return lagged the S&P 500 by 0.15 percentage point a year, compared with just 0.02 point for the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF ('ETF.IVV').
Furthermore, both of these alternatives are less expensive to hold: VOO and IVV both charge just 0.03%, and the State Street SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF (SPYM) charges just 0.02%.
SPY's hgher fees explain most of that gap, but not all of it. Morningstar attributes the rest to SPY’s structure: SPY launched on Jan. 22, 1993, as a unit investment trust. Unlike other alternative ETFs tracking the S&P 500, SPY's prospectus bars the securities lending and futures that newer funds use to earn extra income and keep cash invested.
But SPY offers one advantage for derivatives traders: Massive trading volume. Over the 20 sessions through Oct. 28th, 2026, SPY's trading volume was more than three times VOO, IVV and SPYM combined.
UIT structure precludes futures income
Unit investment trusts (UITs) are entirely passively managed. SPY is a UIT that exlusively holds the common stocks in the S&P 500, with each weight "substantially corresponding" to the index. According to the SPY prospectus, the Trust is therefore not authorized to lend the stocks it holds, or to invest in derivative instruments, including futures contracts, options or swaps.
That means the Trust cannot collect income from lending those stocks. In contrast, Vanguard says its funds lend securities to generate incremental revenue that can enhance returns for shareholders. iShares' prospectus for IVV, dated July 31, 2026, says that fund may lend up to one-third of its assets.
SPY's dividends are held in cash, not reinvested
SPY also holds its dividends in cash. The trustee credits dividends to a non-interest-bearing account and holds the money until the quarterly payout. Any interest the trustee earns on that cash goes to pay fund expenses.
In the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2025, that credit reduced the expenses paid by shareholders by $60.1 million — less than 0.01% of the trust’s $680.3 billion in net assets.
But the larger issue is opportunity cost: When a significant amount of cash is taken out of the stock market portfolio, it can create cash drag, reducing fund returns in rising markets.
Other funds, such as IVV may use index futures to earn income to compensate, but SPY's prospectus prohibits this practice.
Because SPY holds dividends in cash until its quarterly payout, rather than reinvesting them in its portfolio, the fund has lagged several alternatives such as 'EFT:VOO' that keep their dividends invested until just before they make their payouts.
SPY lags peers over trailing 10 years
The 10-year record shows the same pattern. Over the 10 years through Sept. 30, 2026, SPY’s NAV return averaged 15.18% a year, against 15.33% for the index, a gap of 0.15 point a year. IVV averaged 15.30% against its benchmark’s 15.32%, a gap of 0.02 point. On an investment of $10,000, SPY’s record grew to about $41,090 and IVV’s to about $41,520, a difference of roughly $430 over that ten-year period.
SPYs trading volume advantage
Over the 20 sessions through Oct. 28, 2026, SPY traded an average of $29.4 billion of shares a day. VOO averaged $3.9 billion, IVV $3.7 billion and SPYM $1.2 billion. Institutions and day traders can move large orders in SPY quickly without moving the price much. SPY also has a far larger options market than VOO or IVV.
However, this advantage means little for ordinary buy-and-hold investors.
SPY averaged $29.4 billion a day; none of the others reached $4 billion
The bottom line
For buy and hold investors, the record favors the cheaper funds. Over long periods of time, SPY's the cash drag becomes more of an issue as well. Over the past decade, SPY’s NAV return trailed IVV’s by 0.12 percentage point a year.
For active large-volume traders and dedicated option traders, SPY's trading volume benefits those who needs the deepest options market.
Buy and hold investors should not simply sell their SPY shares without considering tax implications on the sale. It makes little sense to realize large taxable capital gains just to save a few dollars a year in expenses or reduce cash drag.
Want more of our stories in Google’s Top Stories? Add etf.net as a preferred source on Google



